Most Buddhist practitioners in the world today, whether lay or ordained, are what the Buddha termed “householders” – people who practice but also maintain a household. You don’t have to study Buddhism very long before you encounter the teaching that you should abandon all worldly entanglements and “leave home” if you really want to achieve the Way. This teaching creates tension for many householder practitioners, especially when we recognize the value of renunciate practices like meditation and retreat. I suggest a way to live with this tension while focusing on the vows that keep you engaged in the world.
Quicklinks to Article Content:
The Koan of Householder Practice (aka Lay Practice)
Teachings That Say “The Household Life is a Dusty Path”
The Benefits of Home Leaving
Renunciate Practices That We All Do
The Koan of Householder Practice (aka Lay Practice)
Since it began, the Buddhist community of practitioners and supporters has been understood as being made up of four parts: Lay men, lay women, ordained men, and ordained women. Traditional ordination in Buddhism involves people “leaving home” and embracing a regimented life of renunciation. Fully ordained monks and nuns live according to hundreds of precepts that require them to live entirely on alms and in close proximity to other monastics, and prohibit them from maintaining their own home, handling money, possessing more than the barest of essentials to survive, and engaging in sex or entertainments of any kind.
In contrast, lay practitioners – those who are not ordained – are called “householders.” (I will usually use the term “householder” instead of “lay” in this discussion, because in other contexts “lay” can refer to someone who isn’t a professional, and therefore someone who might not seriously engage in a practice.) The vast majority of Buddhist practitioners today – whether lay or ordained in anything but the most traditional lineages – are householders. We practice while maintaining a household.
Even if you have a household of one, rent an apartment, and have no pets or plants to take care of, you still have a household. You still have to shop, clean, cook, and pay the bills. You still have a home base that allows you to be effective in the world. A household can end up being a lot of pleasure, but it’s usually also a lot of work, even if you try to keep it simple. And most of us don’t try to keep it simple, right? Home is also a place to raise children, relax and enjoy yourself, surround yourself with beauty and comfort, and socialize with family and friends.
The message that we ought to literally abandon all our worldly entanglements to achieve the Buddha way can be found in many Buddhist teachings throughout the millennia, from the Buddha’s time to the present day. What do we, as householder practitioners, do with such teachings? They can seem like judgmental, dogmatic outliers in an otherwise profound spiritual tradition. Exhortations to abandon the world can seem like a recommendation to be selfish instead of following the path of the bodhisattva, the Mahayana ideal of a practitioner who forgoes the peace of complete liberation to stay in engaged in the world and benefit others. Suggestions that we can’t really practice unless we retreat from the hustle and bustle of the world seem to contradict Zen teachings about how what we are seeking is available to us any moment – right here, right now. After all, the first Chan ancestor in China, Bodhidharma, is supposed to have said, “People who see that their mind is the buddha don’t need to shave their head. Laymen are buddhas too. Unless they see their nature, people who shave their head are simply fanatics.”[i]
If you don’t want to leave home to embrace the path of complete renunciation, or if you can’t do so, how should you relate to the Buddhist emphasis on such practice? Householder practice presents you with a koan, or a spiritual challenge that can’t be explained away intellectually but can be resolved through a shift in your understanding and the way you live. The rewards of resolving a koan aren’t just a decrease in stress or frustration, they include deeper insight into the nature of the Dharma, and greater freedom to manifest our aspirations. It’s well worth wrestling with this koan instead of trying to ignore it.
Teachings That Say “The Household Life is a Dusty Path”
First, let’s explore a couple of Buddhist teachings encouraging you to leave home. The Buddha had many serious lay disciples who achieved high levels of realization, but it was said that they couldn’t achieve the highest level of liberation, or arhatship. Or, it was said, if they were on the verge of arhatship, they would be immediately inspired to leave home if they hadn’t already.
In the Maha-Saccaka Sutta, the Buddha described the householder path like this:
Before my Awakening, when I was still an unawakened Bodhisatta, the thought occurred to me: “Household life is confining, a dusty path. Life gone forth is the open air. It isn’t easy, living in a home, to practice the holy life totally perfect, totally pure, a polished shell. What if I, having shaved off my hair & beard and putting on the ochre robe, were to go forth from the household life into homelessness?”[ii]
After having this thought, the Buddha did indeed leave home and spent the rest of his life as full-time renunciate.
I like the fact that the Buddha says the household path is “dusty” and “confining.” Another translation of this sutta I found said it is “crowded.” It’s not that the household path is steep, incredibly difficult, or full of craggy cliffs. It’s not necessarily a forbidding path, and certainly not an impossible one. It’s just dusty and crowded and messy, at least at times. I think those of us practicing as householders, including me, would agree.
The recommendations to leave home and practice as a monastic continued throughout Buddhism. Jump forward a thousand years to our Japanese Soto Zen ancestor Dogen. Early on in his teaching career, in an essay titled “Bendowa,” or “On the Endeavor of the Way,” he has this exchange with a student:
Question: Home leavers are free from various involvements and do not have hindrances in zazen in pursuit of the way. How can the laity, who are variously occupied, practice single-mindedly and accord with the buddha way, which is unconditioned?
Answer: Buddha ancestors, out of their kindness, have opened the wide gate of compassion in order to let all sentient beings enter realization. Who among humans and heavenly beings cannot enter?
…This just depends on whether or not you have the willingness. It does not matter whether you are a layperson or a home leaver. Those who can discern excellence invariably come to trust in this practice. Those who regard worldly affairs as a hindrance to buddha dharma think only that there is no buddha dharma in the secular world; they do not understand that there is no secular world in buddha dharma.
Great, this sounds like great news for the serious lay practitioner! This resonates with the Zen teaching that everything is sacred, that “there is no secular world in buddha dharma.” However, later in his life, Dogen focused more and more on establishing a strong monastic community. He wrote a long fascicle, or essay, called “The Virtue of Home Leaving.” He first cites many ancient sources that recommend home leaving, and then relates the following exchange:
Question: It is taught that those who receive lay precepts will be born in the deva world [the heavenly realm], attain the bodhisattva way, and experience nirvana. What, then, is the use of receiving the precepts for home leavers?
Answer: Those who receive both types of precepts [lay and home leaver] become awakened. But one type is difficult and the other is easy. Laypeople engage in various works. If they wish to concentrate on the dharma of the way, their business declines. If they are focused on their business, their activity of the way declines. Without choosing one and abandoning the other, laypeople need to practice dharma. This is difficult. Those who have left the household can be free from worldly affairs, distant from confusion, and practice the way wholeheartedly. So, this is easy.
Further, laypeople are noisy and confused while being occupied in many things. The roots of their driving forces are the center of all unwholesome actions. That is why lay practice is difficult. Leaving the household is similar to going out into an empty field where there are no people. They can keep their minds unified and free from thinking. As their thoughts inside retreat, their affairs outside also disappear.”[iii]
As householders we might agree with Dogen’s evaluation of lay practice, at least to some degree. However, then Dogen continues:
Not even one of the buddhas of the past, present, and future in the ten directions became a buddha as a householder. Because there were buddhas in the past, there is leaving the household and receiving the precepts. The attainment of the way by sentient beings invariably depends on their leaving the household and receiving the precepts. Because leaving the household and receiving the precepts is the definitive way of all buddhas, the merit is immeasurable.[iv]
Ouch! How is a householder practitioner to respond to this? It can create great cognitive dissonance when you’re aiming to give yourself over to a spiritual tradition, and feel deeply inspired by its teachings and practices, but then find out many of its most revered teachers would be skeptical that you could attain the way as a householder.
The Benefits of Home Leaving
If you want to lean into the koan of practicing as a householder, I think it’s essential to consider the benefits of home leaving. Regardless of whether you ever would consider such a path, it’s important to understand why so many of our Dharma ancestors praised it.
When evaluating the merits of a practice path, we first need to ask what it is we hope to achieve by walking it. Buddhist teachings encouraging home leaving may leave you asking, “Do I need to leave my family, literally abandon worldly entanglements, and become a monk?” That question should be answered with two more questions: “In order to do what? What do you most want to do with this precious human life?”
I chose to leave home, ordain, and live as a monastic for the better part of ten years because this passage from Henry David Thoreau’s Walden described what I most wanted. He said:
“I went to the woods because I wished to live deliberately, to front only the essential facts of life, and see if I could not learn what it had to teach, and not, when I came to die, discover that I had not lived. I did not wish to live what was not life, living is so dear; nor did I wish to practise resignation, unless it was quite necessary. I wanted to live deep and suck out all the marrow of life, to live so sturdily and Spartan-like as to put to rout all that was not life, to cut a broad swath and shave close, to drive life into a corner, and reduce it to its lowest terms, and, if it proved to be mean, why then to get the whole and genuine meanness of it, and publish its meanness to the world; or if it were sublime, to know it by experience, and be able to give a true account of it in my next excursion.”[v]
If this is what you want above all else, I recommend you leave home. There may be many significant reasons you can’t do so, such as poor health, people you need to care for, or debt, but in most cases, where there’s a will, there’s a way. Often the biggest obstacle to leaving home is fear of stepping away the accepted course of an adult life, giving up financial security, and facing the disapproval of our loved ones. If Thoreau’s words move you like they do me, I encourage you to face your fears and consider exploring monastic life, even if it’s just for a short period of time.
Living a life of literal renunciation in order to concentrate on spiritual practice is a tradition handed down through the millennia, and not just in Buddhism. Body and mind are not separate. Just as the mind calms through the stillness of the body in zazen, much of our practice is realized by enacting it literally and physically—through simplicity, bowing, moving in harmony with others, prioritizing silence, ethical conduct, and so on.
Imagine having no home to care for, no need make money, no intimate partnership to maintain, no family obligations to fulfill, no car to take you off on adventures. You would be free from looking after countless possessions, and because of your lifestyle, precepts, or lack of money, a myriad potentially distracting activities wouldn’t even be an option. In meditation, your mind would be free of the worries of maintaining a household, and no musical riffs or plots of TV shows or novels would intrude. While it’s true that monastics end up having responsibilities within their communities that can keep them quite busy, the ultimate purpose of all their activities is the pursuit, manifestation, and teaching of the Dharma.
What’s striking about mature renunciate monastics is not some moral purity attained by their refusal to engage in the messy world, it’s their radiant joy and peace despite living without most of the things that we count as pleasures – things that make life worth living – in the household life. They have, as Thoreau put it, “to put to rout all that was not life,” and have found it, by experience, to be sublime.
Renunciate Practices That We All Do
The thought of entirely throwing away your lay life for a renunciate one may not appeal to you, but you can appreciate the value of renunciate practices if you have ever attended a silent meditation retreat. Such retreats are like short periods of monastic life. In preparation, you get all your affairs in order. You leave behind your activities, responsibilities, comforts, loved ones, and distractions. You might go to retreat because you are dissatisfied with your life and eager to get away from it, but most practitioners – especially after they have practiced for some time – leave home for a retreat with more than a few pangs of sadness, regret, and trepidation. We learn to love our lives.
When in retreat, though, we set aside social interactions. We don’t speak more than necessary or make eye contact. While this experience of solitude among others can be challenging for some, almost everyone is surprised to find out what a relief it is (at least for a time) not to have to be constantly relating to other people, evaluating their needs, and responding to them. We follow a communal schedule and eat communal meals, so you have almost no decisions to make. We do without reading, music, entertainment, or checking the news, so our minds get very little fresh material with which to fill our meditation.
Renunciation isn’t about withdrawing from bad things, it’s about making space for what otherwise tends to escape our notice. It’s about inviting the Dharma to come forth in the silence. Noticing the intimacy between self and all things. Recognizing our delusions and attachments and seeing a way to greater freedom. Appreciating Suchness, the great, unconditional luminosity of things-as-it-is. Prioritizing what is over the past or the future.
Our meditation practice is also a renunciate practice. For a half hour or an hour – however long we sit – we enact home leaving. We literally set aside all activities and step away from relationships. Internally, we choose silence and stillness.
Living according to moral precepts can also be seen as renunciate practice, even if those precepts aren’t the rules the Buddha devised for monastics. When we vow to live without killing, stealing, abusing intoxicants, or lying, we constrain our options and shape our life in accord with the Dharma. Living an ethical life generally reduces conflict and the generation of negative karma, creating a situation conducive to spiritual practice.
That’s it for today. In part two I will explore the concepts, “monk of body” – someone practicing literal, physical renunciation – and “monk of mind” – someone who remains a householder but practices profound nonattachment. I’ll discuss the most famous lay Buddhist, Vimalakirti, who embodied the ideal of “monk of mind” so completely that he got his own Sutra. Then I’ll talk about how identifying the bodhisattva vows that keep you engaged in the world can help you face the challenges of householder practice. Finally, I’ll address the fact that many of us are part-time monks of body who sometimes long for more monk-of-body practice. We may experience a fair amount of tension between our householder life and our part-time monk-of-body life, but simply accepting this ongoing tension as part of our bodhisattva vows – instead of seeing it as a sign that something is wrong – can help us make peace with it.
Endnotes
[i] Pine, Red. The Zen Teachings of Bodhidharma. New York, NY: North Point Press, 1987. From the “Bloodstream Sermon”
[ii] “Maha-Saccaka Sutta: The Longer Discourse to Saccaka” (MN 36), translated from the Pali by Thanissaro Bhikkhu. Access to Insight (BCBS Edition), 30 November 2013, https://www.accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/mn/mn.036.than.html .
[iii] Tanahashi, Kazuaki, trans., ed. Treasury of the True Dharma Eye: Zen Master Dogen’s Shobo Genzo. Boston, MA: Shambala Publications, 2010.
[iv] Ibid
[v] Thoreau, Henry David. Walden: Life in the Woods. Kindle Edition, original publication 1854.







